[sticky post]About This Journal, and the Reviews Therein
catherinearthur
About This Journal, and the Reviews ThereinCollapse )

SPN-DW: By the Grace of God by slowsunrise (Dean/Cas, Sam, Eleven, OMC PG-13)
catherinearthur
Title: By The Grace Of God
Author: slowsunrise
Artist: sweetestel
Fandom: Supernatural/Doctor Who
Pairing/Characters: Dean, Sam, Cas, The Doctor (11), OC companion, God. Dean/Cas established.
Rating: PG-13
Warnings: Not really the traditional description of God, Dean and Cas gets a baby without m-preg, Supernatural goes AR in Swan Song, The Doctor has a brand new companion.
Word Count: 10,000
Summary: The apocalypse is over for Team Free Will, but one day a blue box crashes on a field. Out steps a man who claims to be a time traveler and his companion. The young man traveling with the Doctor proves to be no other than Cas and Dean's son, not yet born in this time. Soon, the Doctor realizes that if he ever is to be, they need to find God.

Link to masterpost: http://superwho-bb.livejournal.com/10359.html
Download Report: Three posts on LJ.

Review of By the Grace of God by slowsunriseCollapse )

Bottom line: Decent idea, lousy execution.

This review was originally posted to the spnanonhaven Fiction Discuss post

SN: How Much You Mean It by sarcasticsra (NC-17 Dan/Casey, Dana/Calvin)
catherinearthur
Title: How Much You Mean It
Author: sarcasticsra/[personal profile] sarcasticsra
Artist: primalmusic
Fandom: Sports Night
Pairing/Characters: Dan/Casey, Dana/Calvin, Natalie/Jeremy, ensemble
Rating: NC-17/slash/het
Warnings: None.
Word Count: 11,200
Summary: Dan and Casey have been dating for the past four months, something they've been keeping a secret from their friends—or so they think. What happens when an invitation to a network party brings to a head all the fears and insecurities that have been plaguing them?

Link to masterpost: http://smallfandombang.livejournal.com/15226.html
On author's journal: http://scripted-sra.dreamwidth.org/89690.html
Download Report: One post on Dreamwidth.

Review of How Much You Mean It by sarcasticsaraCollapse )

Bottom line: This is great, tight story that re-captures the feel of the series. It has great characters, a good plot, and two lovely romances. Definitely give it a chance.

This review was originally posted to reviewsanon

SPN: "Oubliette" and "Humanity" by mistalagan (Gen, Gabriel, Lucifer, Sam, Dean, Bobby NC-17)
catherinearthur
Title: Oubliette
Author: mistalagan
Fandom: Supernatural
Pairing/Characters: Lucifer, OMCs/Gabriel, Sam, Dean, Sam/Gabriel if you've got the goggles
Rating: NC-17
Warnings: Oh boy. Rape, more rape (aka gangrape), bestiality, bondage, spit-roasting, drugs, humiliation, starvation, lack of kind deities, mention of double penetration, forced orgasm, object insertion, figging, whipping, mummification, watersports, scat, self-harm/attempted suicide
Word Count: 11996
Summary: "You like humans so much, Gabriel? Let's see how much you like being their bitch."

[Full prompt]From SpnKink:

Instead of killing Gabriel at Elysian Fields, Lucifer binds his brother's power (temporarily or permanently, I don't care). He sets Gabriel up in a little underground room, which is locked at all times except when - nightly - a group of men comes in to have some fun. (They have no idea he's an angel - they just know there's a free fuck out of it). They get off on roughing him up; anything that's humiliating and painful goes - DP, object insertion, spit roasting, whips, chains, blindfolds, forced orgasm, etc. Lucifer tells him that if he can make it out of the room and up the stairs to the street, he'll go free. But he's not that big, not compared to these guys, and they always grab him before he can even get to the door.

Maybe some of the men think it's all part of the scene - Gabe's not really unwilling. After all, he never says the safeword his dom gave them.

Bonus points if Team Free Will finds him and stages a rescue.

Please no demons - just normal human sadism.


Link to masterpost: http://mistalagan.livejournal.com/2466.html
Download Report: Two posts on LJ.


Title: Humanity
Author: mistalagan
Artist: mangacrack
Fandom: Supernatural
Pairing/Characters: Gabriel, Sam, Dean, Bobby (pre-Sam/Gabriel if you're looking for it)
Rating: R
Warnings: Allusions to prior rape, associated trauma symptoms, some body horror, some language.
Word Count: 17,200
Summary: Set after 7x04 (the Osiris episode), and sequel to Oubliette (please read warnings). They found Gabriel on a tip from Meg, of all people—beaten and abused, a shadow of what he used to be. It’s not easy taking care of a (temporarily, Sam’s sure—permanently, Gabriel thinks) powerless archangel, especially when dealing with issues of their own. And it would be a bad idea to forget about the Leviathans…

Link to masterpost: http://gabriel-bigbang.livejournal.com/26544.html
Download Report: Three parts on LJ.

Review of Oubliette and Humanity by mistalaganCollapse )

Bottom line: I may very well be showing my whumpy bias here, but I found "Humanity" really satisfying both as a recovery story and as a plotty slice-of-life story for Season 7. Nothing in here is too overblown or overdone, and I think it's well worth giving a read.

This review was originally posted to the spnanonhaven Fiction Discuss post

RPF (SPN): Kaleidoscope by peppervl (Misha Collins/Richard Speight Jr, PG-13)
catherinearthur
Title: Kaleidoscope
Author: peppervl
Artist: candylovinangel
Fandom: Supernatural RPF
Pairing/Characters: Misha Collins/Richard Speight Jr
Rating: PG-13
Warnings: Psychic Powers, not!AU
Word Count: 21,717
Summary: In a world much like ours except where psychic powers are common, Misha can see auras and Richard is a dream walker. When Richard asks Misha for help reading a producer he isn't sure about working with, Misha's power spirals out of control. Desperate for help, he calls on Richard, who find himself drawn into the mystery and fascinated as he gets to know Misha better. Together, they work to get Misha's ability under control, but a mistake leaves Richard feeling guilty and Misha lost. Is it too late, or can they work post out to figure out both how to fix Misha's issue and their changing feelings for each other?

Link to masterpost: http://gabriel-bigbang.livejournal.com/25890.html
Download Report: Four posts on LJ. PDFs with and without page numbers (\O/), PRC/MOBI, and EPUB versions available on Dropbox.

I will also note that every single image, including separators, has alt text. I think I'm in love.

Review of Kaleidoscope by peppervlCollapse )

Bottom line: This is a pleasant little romance with bonus psychic powers on the side. It's not the greatest or most perfect story in the world, but if you're looking for a way to kick back and relax into a story for a while, this is a good way to do it.

This review was originally posted to the spnanonhaven Fiction Discuss post

SPN: Unify by jennytork (Gen, PG13, Gabriel)
catherinearthur
Title: Unify
Author: jennytork
Artist: placeofinsanity
Fandom: Supernatural
Pairing/Characters: Gabriel, background Dean/Lisa
Rating: PG13
Warnings: Goes AU after "Hammer of the Gods". Spoilers for Season 3 through "Live Free And Twihard", then takes a hard right turn into AU territory.
Word Count: 16,614
Summary: I needed a temporary vessel until my new True Vessel reached adulthood. I just didn't know how much work it would take!

Link to masterpost: http://gabriel-bigbang.livejournal.com/26810.html
Download Report: Download Report: Five posts on LJ.

This review was originally posted to the spnanonhaven Fiction Discuss post

Review of Unify by jennytorkCollapse )

Bottom line: I can't buy the premise, the characters are way OOC, and the writing does nothing to convince me that anything in the story is remotely plausible.

This review was originally posted to the spnanonhaven Fiction Discuss post

SPN: Feel the Freedom Like No Tomorrow by tasogareika
catherinearthur
Title: Feel The Freedom Like No Tomorrow
Author: tasogareika
Artist: nanyakanya
Fandom: Supernatural
Pairing/Characters: Jimmy (and the Novaks), Sam, Dean, Gabriel, Bobby, God/Castiel, the Leviathans and an OC. Also includes A DRAGON, just because. Gen overall, with mentions of canon Jimmy/Amelia and a smattering of (pre) Dean/Cas overtones
Rating: PG-13
Warnings: Deviates from canon after 6.22 (or the early part of 7.01 depending on your view), so spoilers are up to there—although some season seven stuff also lurks about (mainly the existence of the Leviathans). This fic also contains weird psychological probings, delusional nutjobs, more angst than strictly necessary and other weird stuff (like A DRAGON). Also Gabriel, whose (re)existence alone totally deserves a warning of its own.
Word Count: 54,000
Summary: Jimmy Novak awakens back to a world where the Apocalypse did not happen and Castiel is apparently going around the world with his face and proclaiming himself 'God'—a 'God' who is directly linked to Jimmy, and where Jimmy happens to be the key factor in stopping this false God with help from the Winchesters, Bobby and a formerly dead archangel-cum-pagan god.

Link to masterpost: http://jimmybigbang.livejournal.com/7437.html
Download Report: Eight posts on LJ. Seven posts on LJ. Also on AO3. PDF available on Mediafire.

Review of Feel The Freedom Like No Tomorrow by tasogareikaCollapse )

Bottom line: This is nice, long, plotty story with good insights into the characters. If you're the least bit interested in Jimmy Novak, try it.

This review was originally posted to the spnanonhaven Fiction Discuss post

SPN/Haven: Hunter's Haven by briarwood (Gen Audrey Parker, John Winchester R)
catherinearthur
Title: Hunter's Haven
Author: briarwood
Artist: bdrixhaettc
Fandom: Supernatural/Haven
Pairing/Characters: Audrey Parker, Reverend Driscoll, Duke Crocker, Nathan Wuornos, John Winchester, Gabriel
Rating: Mature
Warnings: Spoilers for Haven up to 2.10: Who, What, Where, Wendigo and for Supernatural up to 5.22: Swan Song
Word Count: 24,500
Summary: Haven, Maine is a town full of mysteries, but even among the weirdness, John Winchester is a puzzle. At first, Audrey Parker is only intrigued. When a series of strange deaths appears to involve him, she decides she needs to solve the puzzle soon. But John, too, is trying to solve one of Haven's mysteries, and this one involves Audrey herself.

Link to masterpost: http://john-w-bigbang.livejournal.com/8028.html
Download Report: Six posts on LJ. One post on Dreamwidth. Also on AO3.

Review of Hunter's Haven by briarwoodCollapse )

Bottom line: This is a darn good story. The characters are good, the writing is solid, and the plot-lines are interesting and engaging. Even if you're not familiar with the canon of Haven, I think you can enjoy this.

This review was originally posted to the spnanonhaven Fiction Discuss post

SPN: Roadhouse Ink by epicycles (Gabriel, Dean Gen R)
catherinearthur
Title: Roadhouse Ink
Author: epicycles
Artist: cassiopeia7
Fandom: Supernatural
Pairing/Characters: Gen
Rating: PG-13/R
Warnings: Set in a universe that goes AU in late Season 2, but contains spoilers up through Season 5. Content warnings only for brief violence, bad language and the occasional mild innuendo.
Word Count: 16,000
Summary: This is basically a 16000 word excuse to indulge my tattoo kink.

AU. After an injury, Dean retires from hunting to become a tattoo artist, slipping anti-possession symbols into all the art. One day two djinn -- the supposed Trickster and his younger brother -- turn up on Dean's doorstep, needing his help and offering a wish in return.

Link to masterpost: http://gabriel-bigbang.livejournal.com/28768.html
Download Report: Download Report: Two posts on LJ.

Review of Roadhouse Ink by epicyclesCollapse )

Bottom line: It's good. Try it.

This review was originally posted to the spnanonhaven Fiction Discuss post

SPN: You Know You've Yet by inalasahl (Sam/Gabriel, NC-17)
catherinearthur
Title: You Know You've Yet
Author: inalasahl
Artist: rubystandish
Fandom: Supernatural
Pairing/Characters: Sam/Gabriel
Rating: NC-17
Warnings: Consent Issues [More detail with story spoilers](Sam uses a lust spell on Gabriel to as part of a pagan sacrifice to force Gabriel into granting him a favor. The sex is rough on Sam and the effects of the spell cause Gabriel to enjoy it.) [Reveiw note: This story also contains spoilers for episode 7x17 "The Born-Again Identity."]
Word Count: 15,538
Summary: Sam goes back in time to get Gabriel's blood to save Dean. But the two of them have a history no one knows about, and Gabriel demands a favor in return.

Link to masterpost: http://gabriel-bigbang.livejournal.com/28630.html
Download Report: AO3 only.

Review of You Know You've Yet by inalasahlCollapse )

Bottom line: If you're desperate to read a Sam/Gabriel romance, this might satisfy on that level. I did enjoy the Sam/Gabriel parts of this, mostly because they were both insecure and skittish at times, and both were confident and agressive at times. (Just like real people!) But there were also a lot of cliches in the romance and the writing wasn't enough to pull it out. If you want a good plot, skip this one.

This review was originally posted to the spnanonhaven Fiction Discuss post

SPN: Spare the Rod by ghostwriter056 (John/Dean, R)
catherinearthur
Title: Spare The Rod
Author: ghostwriter056
Artist: purple_carpets
Fandom: Supernatural
Pairing/Characters: John/Dean
Rating: R
Warnings: pseudo incest (Dean is from an alternate reality), consensual sex between an adult and a minor (Dean is 15), discussion and non-graphic descriptions of the physical and psychological abuse of a minor. Sexual content is discussed, but very little of it is graphic. {Review note--I feel the consent in the story is problematic. I've discussed it in more depth in the review.]
Word Count: 19,800
Summary: Dean Winchester died on one of his first hunts when he was only thirteen. Two years later and John hasn't forgiven himself for not protecting his son better. He barely sees Sam and he's thrown himself even farther into hunting. For once, John's at the right place at the right time and an unplanned visit to a fairy ring results in a gift he never expected, the return of Dean. Only this isn't John's Dean. This Dean's a fifteen year old kid from another reality where John never learned the truth about Mary's death, but rather took to drinking and became a mean, abusive drunk.

Link to masterpost: http://john-w-bigbang.livejournal.com/7325.html
Download Report: Six posts on LJ. Also available without art on AO3. PDFs with and without art available on Mediafire.

Review of Spare The Rod by ghostwriter056Collapse )

Bottom line: If you're a die-hard John/Dean fan who isn't squicked or put off by any of the things I've mentioned, give it a go, but set your expectations low. Most of the rest of the planet, give it a pass.

This review was originally posted to the spnanonhaven Fiction Discuss post

SPN: Homo Homini Lupus Est by neotoma
catherinearthur
Title: Homo Homini Lupus Est
Author: neotoma
Artist: satavaisa
Fandom: Supernatural
Pairing/Characters: Gabriel/Jo, Gabriel/Kali, Gabriel/Sam, Dean/Castiel (background), Castiel/Gabriel (implied)
Word count: 30,066
Rating: NC-17
Warnings: Werewolf AU, MPRG/hermamphroditic pregnancy, rape-recovery, alpha/beta dynamics, sex toys, Castiel and the Winchesters as antagonists
Summary: Gabriel ran away from his home and his pack. He had his reasons. But a werewolf without a pack is a vulnerable thing -- Gabriel skids through his life until he ends up on Kali's doorstep. His life seems to have come together, until a face from his past comes to town, and Gabriel is hauled back to his family, and the grasp of his brother, Lucifer.

Link to masterpost: http://gabriel-bigbang.livejournal.com/27900.html
Download report: Five posts on Dreamwidth, also on AO3.

Review of Homo Homini Lupus Est by neotomaCollapse )

Bottom line: There are a lot of really good things about this story, including the rare appearances of Jo and Kali. The one huge potential deal-breaker isn't a big part, word-count-wise, of the story. I would encourage you to give it a try (possibly with some search and replace if you can roll that way). I think it's worth it.

This review was originally posted to the spnanonhaven Fiction Discuss post

SPN: Black Cat Magicks by pandionpandeus (Dean/Gabriel PG-13)
catherinearthur
Title: Black Cat Magicks
Author: pandionpandeus
Artist: shinymessoyay
Fandom: Supernatural
Pairing/Characters: Dean/Gabriel (and background Sam/Castiel if you’ve got your slash goggles on too tight)
Rating: PG-13
Warnings: Pretty much none. :)
Word Count: 17,500
Summary: When he saves a witch's injured familiar--who turns out to be the witch himself--Dean unwittingly puts himself in the middle of another witch's play for power. Between threats of death and destruction from Zachariah and Gabriel showing up in his dreams, Dean has to decide who to trust and soon, before Zachariah tries to kill Gabriel again.

Link to masterpost: http://gabriel-bigbang.livejournal.com/24894.html
Download Report: Two parts on LJ.

Review of Black Cat Magicks by pandionpandeusCollapse )

Bottom line: This is a good story with a solid plot and decent writing. Give it a try.

This review was originally posted to the spnanonhaven Fiction Discuss post

SPN: Worth Saving Me by wolfish_willow (Gen Sam, Dean, Ellen, Bobby, Jo PG-13)
catherinearthur
Title: Worth Saving Me
Author: wolfish_willow
Artist: sailorhathor
Fandom: Supernatural
Pairing/Characters: Sam, Dean, Ellen, Bobby, Jo // General, no pairings
Rating: PG-13
Warnings: mean!John, language, violence (I don't think the violence is any worse than what's on Show)
Word Count: ~28,000
Summary: Pre-series AU, Alternating POV. Nearly 9 years after Dean's little brother ran away, Dean walks into the Roadhouse for the first time. He's taken by surprise at the sight of Sam, now an adult, acting like a brother to a blond named Jo, and calling the bar's owner, Ellen, "Mom". Sam looks terrified to see him and the shot gun Ellen trains on Dean's chest leaves him angry and confused when all he wants to do is grab his brother into a hug and never let him out of his sight again. And soon, Dean will find out the truth behind why and how Sam left them 8 years ago.

Link to masterpost: http://angstbigbang.livejournal.com/6576.html
Download Report: Seven parts on LJ. There is no AO3 post linked on the master post, but when I accidently hit the page without style=mine (*not* recommended--dark pink text on a brick-red background) I saw a link to the author's AO3 account on the journal sidebar.

So, on AO3: http://archiveofourown.org/works/363508

Review of Worth Saving Me by wolfish_willowCollapse )

Bottom line: Woobie!Sam fans, today is your id's lucky day. Everyone else, save yourself the pain.

This review was originally posted to the spnanonhaven Fiction Discuss post

SPN: A Road That Takes Me Home by slowsunrise (Sam/Gabriel NC-17)
catherinearthur
Title: A Road That Takes Me Home
Author: slowsunrise
Artist: myfriendfredric
Fandom: Supernatural
Pairing/Characters: Sam/Gabriel with a side of Dean/Cas
Rating: NC-17
Warnings: Pirate AU, sword fights, cursing, m/m sex scene. Using the names Castiel, Gabriel and Balthazar, but no real plot elements from canon SPN.
Word Count: ~22,000
Summary: A Pirate AU. Sam is out looking for his brother at sea, when he falls overboard. Before he drowns, he is picked up by a crew of pirates, and among them he finds Dean. Gabriel, the captain, offers Sam a place on the ship, but Sam doesn't want anything to do with pirates, and especially not Gabriel. On the journey back to a harbor to drop Sam off, though, he might just change his mind.

Link to masterpost: http://gabriel-bigbang.livejournal.com/24818.html
Download Report: Three parts on LJ. PDF with art on Mediafire.

Review of A Road That Takes Me Home by slowsunriseCollapse )

Bottom line: I'm afraid this didn't even work for me as escapist porn, idfic, or badfic.

This review was originally posted to the spnanonhaven Fiction Discuss post

RPF (SPN): I Ain't Been Nothin But Bad by gedry (Misha Collins/Richard Speight Jr NC-17)
catherinearthur
Title: I Ain't Been Nothin But Bad
Author: gedry
Artist: heard_the_owl
Fandom: Supernatural RPF
Pairing/Characters: Richard/Misha
Rating: NC-17
Warnings/Spoilers: Utter crack, Disney fusion with Prep and Landing, Elves.
Word Count: 15,146
Summary: Richard's been working as the Director of the Nice list for over a hundred years, he's good at his job, helping Santa and his other elves make Christmas happen on time for all the human boys and girls. But this year is different, this year he has to work with the new Director of the Naughty list, Misha Collins. Which wouldn't be a problem if he hadn't been Richard's drunken one night stand the night before he started. But they're both professionals, how hard can it be to get the job done?

Link to masterpost: http://gabriel-bigbang.livejournal.com/23434.html
Download Report: Two posts on LJ.

Review of I Ain't Been Nothin But Bad by gedryCollapse )

Bottom line: It's not a perfect story. But it's pretty darn good at what it does, and it's a fun and sweet way to spend an hour.

This review was originally posted to the spnanonhaven Fiction Discuss post

SPN: Heart In A Riot by scyllaya (Gabriel/Dean NC-17)
catherinearthur
Title: Heart In A Riot
Author: scyllaya
Artist: cashay
Fandom: Supernatural
Pairing/Characters: Gabriel/Dean
Rating: NC-17
Warnings: Slavery, graphic sexual content [light dub-con (slavery), mild D/S (master-slave)], cursing, blood [graphic injury], mentions of violence [Reviewer note: I would disagree with calling the sexual content "light dub-con." I feel that it's non-con/rape, and I've discussed this in the review.]
Word Count: 55,000
Summary: In a time where the creatures of the Five Worlds rule and control everything; humanity has fallen into slavery many years ago, with only a few willing to still fight for them. Dean Winchester awaits his seemingly grim future in an auction house, which is achingly similar to the one where his brother was torn away from him thirteen years ago. He doesn’t realize how the second the hammer falls down, it’s not only his fate that is sealed. He unknowingly lands in a life where he may have a chance to help change not just his own future, but the fate of humanity as well.

Link to masterpost: http://gabriel-bigbang.livejournal.com/23864.html
Download Report: Thirteen parts on LJ. PDF on Mediafire.

Review of Heart In A Riot by scyllayaCollapse )

Bottom line: This was well-written with some good world-building. If you like slave-verse stories that confront the consent issues, definitely give this on a shot. Just up the warnings a few notches.

This review was originally posted to the spnanonhaven Fiction Discuss post

SPN: Hush Little Baby by linda92595 (Dean/Jimmy PG-15)
catherinearthur
Title: Hush Little Baby
Author: linda92595
Artist: nicole_sill
Fandom: Supernatural
Pairing/Characters: Dean/Jimmy, past Dean/Castiel
Rating: PG-15 due to violence and language
Warnings: references to past Dean/Castiel, Mpreg, violence, angst
Word Count: 10,844
Summary: After the Apocalypse is averted, Castiel and the other angels leave Earth and Dean can‘t decide if he loves Castiel or Jimmy. Dean decides that Jimmy would be better off without him and pushes him into leaving without knowing that Jimmy is pregnant with Dean’s child.

Link to masterpost: http://jimmybigbang.livejournal.com/8178.html
Download Report: Three posts on LJ. (Not linked from post to post, so you have to open parts from the masterpost.)

Review of Hush Little Baby by linda92595Collapse )

Bottom line: You might possibly be entertained by the sheer WTFery.

This review was originally posted to the spnanonhaven Fiction Discuss post

RPF (SPN): Always Knew by dante_s_hell (Jared/Jensen NC-17)
catherinearthur
Title: Always Knew
Author: dante_s_hell
Artist: ghoulfang
Fandom: Supernatural RPS
Pairing/Characters: Jared/Jensen
Rating: NC17
Warnings: Dom/Sub themes
Word Count: 6,000
Summary: Jared always knew where Jensen belonged. He just had to show Jensen.

Link to masterpost: http://slaveexchange.livejournal.com/6284.html
Download Report: One post on LJ.

Review of Always Knew by dante_s_hellCollapse )

Bottom line: Although the writing was good and I enjoyed the relationship itself, I felt that the way Jared handled the D/s aspect of the relationship was very problematic and that no acknowledgment of this was made in the context of the story.

This review was originally posted to the spnanonhaven Fiction Discuss post

SPN: Ghost in the Machine by ghostwriter056
catherinearthur
Title: The Ghost in the Machine
Author: ghostwriter056
Artist: reapertownusa
Fandom: Supernatural
Pairing/Characters: John/Dean, Bobby/Eleanor, Sam/Castiel
Rating: NC17
Warnings: Occasional graphic slash, temporary canon character death, consensual incest, mentioned underage, slight violence, plays fast and loose with Lovecraftian mythos, MAJOR SPOILERS FOR THE SEASON 6 FINALE
Word Count: 25,107
Summary: Castiel, now believing himself to be God, seeks to gain Sam and Dean's allegiance. Bringing John Winchester back from the dead is just the beginning. Bobby is reunited Eleanor as they try to get to the bottom of what killed H.P. Lovecraft's dinner party guests and what's making Cas think he's God before it's too late for them or for Cas.

Link to masterpost: http://scifibigbang.livejournal.com/57140.html
Download report: Five posts on LJ. PDFs with and without art available on Mediafire. AO3.

Review of The Ghost in the Machine by ghostwriter056Collapse )


Bottom line: This won't be joining several of the author's other stories in my Schmoopy Daddy-Kink Incest Re-reads For a Rainy Day pile.

This review was originally posted to the spnanonhaven Fiction Discuss post

SPN: Checkmate Ends the Game by free_pirate (Sam/Dean, Sam/Jess NC-17)
catherinearthur
Title: Checkmate Ends the Game
Author: free_pirate
Artist: clex_monkie89
Fandom: Supernatural
Pairing/Characters: Sam/Dean, Sam/Jess
Rating: NC-17
Warnings: Incest, infidelity and all else the above pairings imply
Word Count: ~38k
Summary: Preseries AU. The only thing Sam has of his father's is an old journal. It's written like a primer for every nightmarish thing he's ever heard of and several that he hasn't – things that can't possibly be real. A chance meeting in a bar stirs something in his blood that he can't quite explain. Dean Winchester is mysterious, maybe a little bit dangerous, but he shows Sam something he didn't know he was missing. And hunting is just the beginning.

Link to masterpost: http://spn-j2-bigbang.livejournal.com/257956.html
Download Report: Four parts on LJ. PDF on 4Shared.

Review of Checkmate Ends the Game by free_pirateCollapse )

Bottom line: If you're looking for a readable piece of Sam/Dean AU with some decent angst, give this one a try. You probably won't put it on your best story ever list, but you probably won't feel that you've wasted your time, either.

This review was originally posted to the spnanonhaven Fiction Discuss post

RPF (SPN): Hockey Nights by eviltwin
catherinearthur
Title: Hockey Nights
Author: eviltwin
Artist: cassiopeia7
Fandom: Supernatural/CW RPF
Pairing/Characters: Jensen/Jared, Jensen/OMCs, Chris Kane/Beth Riesgraf
Rating: Adult
Warnings: (None given)
Word Count: 21,781
Summary: Jared's a successful young goalkeeper for an NHL team and his career is on the way up all the time. Jensen plays University hockey and meets him thanks to his friend's outrageous behavior at one of Jared's games. But Jared's not ready to tell the world the truth about who he is. When Jensen gets a chance to play for the same team as Jared, he tries to prove that neither of them has to hide.

Link to masterpost: http://spn-j2-bigbang.livejournal.com/246964.html
Download Report: Five posts on LJ. PDF available on Sendspace.

Review of Hockey Nights by eviltwinCollapse )

Bottom line: I don't feel I wasted my time reading it, but it's not on my must-reads. If you've read about the problems I and the other nonnies have with it and think they won't bother you [see the original discussion thread or the posts reproduced under the review cut], you'll probably like it well enough. I just wouldn't prioritize it.

This review was originally posted to the spnanonhaven Fiction Discuss post

SPN: Fortress and Static by glasslogic (Sam/Dean, NC-17)
catherinearthur
Title: Fortress
Author: glasslogic
Artist: silviakundera
Fandom: Supernatural
Pairing/Characters: Sam/Dean, very brief mentions of Sam/Ruby
Rating: NC-17
Warnings: dub-con, blood-play, ...bad language? But hey - it has a quest, and a road-trip!
Word Count: 94,242
Summary: Seven years ago Dean Winchester paid his due to the Crossroads Demon and fell into Hell. Grief almost killed Sam, a demon blood addiction came closer, but he rid himself of demonic attachments and spent years building himself a prison where no demon can set foot, determined to take himself out of the apocalyptic game that had crushed his family. But each year on Earth is an eternity in Hell, and now Dean is back. Angry, powerful, and demonic; he has a plan to wreck vengeance on those who destroyed his life. A plan that will shake the foundations of the Pit and send shock-waves into Heaven. Dragging a reluctant Sam in his wake, will Dean manage to pull it off before the combined legions of Hell get their act together enough to stop him?

Link to masterpost: http://glasslogic.livejournal.com/10886.html
Download Report: Eleven parts on LJ. Epub, HTML and PDF versions available on Sendspace.

Title: Static
Author: glasslogic
Artist: ely_wa
Fandom: Supernatural
Pairing/Characters: Sam/Dean
Rating: R/NC-17
Warnings: dub-con, blood, language...
Word Count: 62k
Summary: Lilith's plans are in shambles and the door to Lucifer's cage has been well and truly lost, but Dean is still a demon and Sam is still bound to him with a stolen curse of sex and blood. All things considered, though, Sam's life could be worse and he is making peace not just with Dean, but with his own growing psychic gifts and the barrage of seemingly meaningless visions they inflict on him. But strange winds are starting to blow and after a series of disasters strike, Sam discovers that the greatest danger may be in the secrets that still lie between him and Dean. If Sam can't fix things before time runs out it won't be the Apocalypse, but it will still be the end of the world.

Link to masterpost: http://spn-j2-bigbang.livejournal.com/246569.html
Download Report: Eight posts on LJ.

Review of Fortress and Static by glasslogicCollapse )

Bottom line: I really liked both of them. I felt that they were plotty, intricate, well-thought-out stories that pushed the envelope of what Sam and Dean were willing to do for each other. I was also very intrigued by the author's world-building of Heaven and Hell and her concept of how the macroverse of Supernatural worked.

That said, I also think that this is one of those "love or hate" series. My advice is to give the series a solid chance. If none of the issues I mention in the reivew is an absolute deal-breaker, I say give yourself at least the first two chapters of "Fortress" to see if you fall in the love camp.

This review was originally posted to the spnanonhaven Fiction Discuss post

?

Log in